Thursday, 29 January 2009

forex/Oanda Review - A Review of the Oanda Forex Brokerage

Best Features

  • No Minimum Opening Deposit
  • Custom Lot Sizes
  • Trade Directly on the charts
  • Custom News Feed
  • Demo Accounts Never Expire
  • Sub Accounts

Least liked features

  • no hedging

Demo Accounts

The Oanda demo account is virtually identical to the live account. The price feed is exactly the same as the live account and demo accounts never expire.

Customer Service

Oanda provides customer service by email, chat, and phone. Oanda seems to typically be responsive to request for service via any of the 3 methods. Emails sometimes take up to 24 hours to be returned depending on the issue.

Spreads

Oanda provides variable spreads, which means that spreads can change depending on market conditions. Most of Oanda’s spreads are extremely competitive during normal market conditions. The only time that the spread jumping will usually prove to be a problem is if you are trading directly around a major news release. For example, the EUR/USD typically trades with a spread of 0.9 – 1.9 pips under normal market conditions. During a news release the spread for the EUR/USD can go as high as 10 pips.

Leverage

Oanda only allows 50:1 leverage. Many traders might consider this a disadvantage, but I consider it to be like selling a gun with a safety on it. 50:1 leverage is sufficient for forex trading. Leverage set at 100:1 and higher can be dangerous and cause you to make oversized trades just because you can.

Currency Pairs

  • AUD/CAD
  • AUD/JPY
  • AUD/NZD
  • AUD/USD
  • CAD/JPY
  • CHF/JPY
  • EUR/AUD
  • EUR/CAD
  • EUR/CHF
  • EUR/CZK
  • EUR/DKK
  • EUR/GBP
  • EUR/HUF
  • EUR/JPY
  • EUR/NOK
  • EUR/NZD
  • EUR/PLN
  • EUR/SEK
  • EUR/TRY
  • EUR/USD
  • GBP/CAD
  • GBP/CHF
  • GBP/JPY
  • GBP/USD
  • NZD/CAD
  • NZD/JPY
  • NZD/USD
  • USD/CAD
  • USD/CHF
  • USD/CNY
  • USD/CZK
  • USD/DKK
  • USD/HKD
  • USD/HUF
  • USD/INR
  • USD/JPY
  • USD/MXN
  • USD/NOK
  • USD/PLN
  • USD/SAR
  • USD/SEK
  • USD/SGD
  • USD/TRY
  • USD/TWD
  • USD/ZAR
As an added bonus, Oanda also allows you to trade gold and silver against the dollar. The symbols are XAG/USD (silver) and XAU/USD (gold).

Charting

Oanda comes with a decent charting package. A reasonable amount of technical indicators are available and you can trade directly on the charts. Oanda allows you to set limit orders and move stops visually. This works extremely well for technical trading.

Opening an Account

Opening an account was simple. Oanda takes 1-2 business days to check your identity, but after that you are ready to go.

Overall Grade: A

Oanda provides good customer service, excellent reliability, and a reasonably good platform to trade with. They even provide a newsfeed service for free with your account. This is an excellent broker, particularly if you are just getting started.

forex/FXCM Review

Top Features

  • Full Hedging
  • Funding by Credit Card
  • Microlot Trading (FXCM Micro)

Least Liked Features

  • No trading on US holidays

Demo Accounts

The FXCM demo account is very easy to open. It performs very much like the live account. It is sadly limited to only 30 days.

Customer Service

FXCM offers customer service by email, phone, and live chat. The customer service at FXCM has been a little slow the few times I have needed to contact them by email. Overall the customer service speed is fair, but not great.

Spreads

FXCM provides variable spreads, which means that spreads can change depending on market conditions. Spreads can widen without warning. In the case of FXCM, not all of their spreads are competitive and their spreads can expand widely depending on which markets are open and which currency pairs you are trading.

Leverage

FXCM allows 100:1 for standard accounts, 200:1 for mini accounts, and 400:1 for micro accounts

Currency Pairs

  • AUD/CAD
  • AUD/CHF
  • AUD/JPY
  • AUD/NZD
  • AUD/USD
  • CAD/JPY
  • CHF/JPY
  • EUR/AUD
  • EUR/CAD
  • EUR/CHF
  • EUR/GBP
  • EUR/JPY
  • EUR/NZD
  • EUR/TRY
  • EUR/USD
  • GBP/AUD
  • GBP/CAD
  • GBP/CHF
  • GBP/JPY
  • GBP/NZD
  • GBP/USD
  • NZD/JPY
  • NZD/USD
  • USD/CAD
  • USD/CHF
  • USD/HKD
  • USD/JPY
  • USD/SGD
  • USD/TRY
  • USD/ZAR

Charting Package

FXCM comes standard with a Marketscope charting system integrated into the trading platform. Marketscope comes with many technical indicators and is highly configurable in terms of colors and style. It has a nice feature that will allow you to open 3 charts of the same currency pair with different time frames and link them together. With the charts linked, you can change the currency pair on one chart and all the charts will also change.

Ease of Opening an Account

I have had two separate experiences with FXCM in regards to opening an account. On the first account, even though I had funded the account, there was a 5 day delay in the account becoming tradable. I lost a week of trading time. The second account was open and tradable within 24 hours. I even received a phone call from a representative within 10 minutes of submitting the application.

Overall Grade: B

FXCM is a reliable broker. The hedging feature allows great flexibility for scalpers in particular. The spreads are ok, not the greatest for all currency pairs, but reasonably tight spreads most of the time on the majors. Customer service seems dependable in most cases and the platform is very stable.